[00:00] Jen Allen-Knuth: The guy called me and literally screamed until I was sobbing, because I thought I was going to win this amazing deal.
[00:08] Tim Geisert: A lot of people think sales is easy. They're not the ones carrying a number. Yes, sales is a rewarding profession, but it's filled with ups and downs, yeses and many nos. The successful ones have a secret: they have a plan, a belief, something special that keeps them going. We find those sellers and revenue leaders, we hand them the mic, and we learn from what they've learned. Hi, I'm your host, Tim Geisert, and this is Sales Matters — for and by the people who deliver a number.
[00:39] Tim Geisert: Hello, Jen. How are you?
[00:41] Jen Allen-Knuth: I am amazing after seeing that hat. Is that something you wear all the time, or is this a special occasion?
[00:47] Tim Geisert: I wear it everywhere I go, all the time. I never, ever take it off.
[00:51] Jen Allen-Knuth: Good. Let me just keep living that in my life.
[00:55] Tim Geisert: Thanks for doing this, Jen. We have Jen Allen-Knuth. So I'm going to jump right in — I've got a bunch of questions for you. You carried a bag for 18 years, at CEB, which then turned into Gartner, right? Back in the Challenger days — probably very exciting times.
[01:18] Jen Allen-Knuth: Right.
[01:20] Tim Geisert: So I've got a question for you: what was the hardest year of your sales career?
[01:24] Jen Allen-Knuth: Easy: 2008. 2008 is the year before The Challenger Sale came out. And I would love to sit here and say I was a Challenger from the beginning. I wasn't. I was a relationship builder through and through. So 2008 was the hardest year. It's probably also the year I learned the most about sales, because I was an account manager at the time, and it was, "Love you. You've been great to us. It's not you, it's us." Canceling, and just watching my book of business erode right in front of my face. I remember certain CMOs — because at the time I was working with CMOs in enterprise — big-name people almost in tears on the phone, because they were making these calls, laying people off, with uncertainty about their personal wealth. It's not even close. Selling a live sales training program during COVID was tough, but 2008 was monumentally the hardest.
[02:23] Tim Geisert: I was one of those CMOs. What in the world were you thinking, starting your own business?
[02:31] Jen Allen-Knuth: When I was at CEB, I would go to every speaking engagement I could where Brent Adamson or Matt Dixon or Dave Anderson was speaking — any of these legends who were just so good at commanding a room of C-level executives. I'd go and watch them, and there was always a part of me that thought, "Wow, that seems like such a cool job, if I could figure out a way to do it." So that was in the back of my mind. But at Challenger, it got to a point — to be honest, it got acquired by private equity, and I was like, "I don't know if I agree with where the company's going." To me, professional services is a very people-oriented thing. They started to move into more of a recurring-revenue type of model, which made sense for the business, and that felt like a natural opt-out for me.
So when I left in December '22, I was like, "All right, I'm going to do this," and I booked some sales kickoffs. And then a tech company came to me and said, "Do you want to do this really cool community growth role at our company?" And I was like, that sounds very safe and stable, and there are benefits. So I kind of chickened out and took that job, did it for nine months, and then left to start my own business. I always like to be honest about that. It's not like I just ripped the Band-Aid off and went whole hog. I definitely had some unease about it in the beginning.
[03:44] Tim Geisert: I think we all do, whenever we make a big shift, a big change. So, going back into your history: what was the most impactful thing in your life that made you who you are today?
[03:55] Jen Allen-Knuth: In my life?
[03:56] Tim Geisert: Yeah. We're not talking small stuff here. This podcast is serious, heavy stuff. We want to know your deep, dark insights.
[04:05] Jen Allen-Knuth: Yeah. I think getting good at work was a very big thing for me. I wouldn't have described myself as a super confident person. I couldn't walk into a room and feel like I could own the room, right? I would walk up to everybody, have nice conversations, ask questions, get them talking about themselves. But when I started to figure out sales, it made me feel like I almost had a superpower. And that superpower gave me more confidence in how I moved through my relationships, my friendships, and just the basic little dealings in life. I think that's probably why I stayed in sales as long as I did: I was almost addicted to that feeling — the confidence it gave me.
[05:01] Tim Geisert: Did that start young? That feeling good about sales? For example, what did you do when you were young to make money? Were you snakebitten early?
[05:15] Jen Allen-Knuth: I was not hustling on the corner doing lemonade stands. My first job was being a hostess. I was terrible at it — I got fired. Then I went to a drugstore, Eckerd Drug, which I think is out of business now. What I liked about it was that there was an option to move up. You start as a cashier, and then you could move up to assistant manager. And I think that's what lit the spark. I became an assistant manager — the youngest in the district, obviously, because most people my age weren't trying to be that. I liked seeing that if you really put the work in, you could get to the next level, and with that came more responsibility and more money. So I guess it probably started when I was 15, when I got that job, because it showed me that what you put in is ultimately what you get out.
[06:06] Tim Geisert: How did that manifest itself when you got your first real sales job, at CEB?
[06:11] Jen Allen-Knuth: I think I had a really good work ethic coming in. I was raised in a family with a really good work ethic, so that was built into me, and the job at Eckerd showed me that if you really apply yourself, you can get to the next level. When I first started at CEB, I worked for the most extraordinary woman. I came in almost like an SDR supporting her, and she could just command a room. She would get on the phone with a Fortune 500 CMO and hold her own. She could manage a conversation unlike anyone I'd ever seen. So when I got to CEB, I was like, "Okay, I know I can work hard enough. I idolize her. I want to be like her." And I just studied her.
When she left, about eight months into my sales job, I went to her boss and said, "Can I have her job?" And she said, "No, you cannot. We won't pay you to do her job, but until we hire someone else, you can do her job and not get paid for it." That's where the work ethic clicked in. I was like, "All right, I'm going to do it." So I did it, and a couple of months later they hadn't found anybody. I went back to the office and said, "I've been doing the job. The renewal rates are awesome. Could I take the job?" And this time it was a yes. So all throughout my career I've felt that if you really work hard, you can get where you want to go.
[07:37] Tim Geisert: So what did you learn from her? What were the top three things?
[07:41] Jen Allen-Knuth: Number one: you don't use your title, you don't use your resume, you don't use any of that. You earn respect through the conversation you deliver. I found that really cool, because I was young — I went to college for recreation and park management. No one was going to be blown away by my resume. And I thought, man, that feels like you have so much control over your destiny. If I just work really hard and learn how to do this well, I can be really good at this job. So number one was: respect is earned by the conversation, not by your credentials.
Number two was how to be exactly who you are — not the sales persona you see in movies and TV shows. Jesse was really good at showing up in a room. She could make you laugh, but she could also hold you accountable to something you said. And I remember thinking, she's not like the movie character. She's not The Wolf of Wall Street, but she's really commanding — such a commanding presence in her own way. She knew I idolized her, but she said, "Don't try to be me. You can be inspired by me, but you will be your best by being exactly who you are." And who I am is witty and funny and all those things. I've seen that be true across my career: the more I let that out, the better my results are.
And number three: never point the finger anywhere else. If there's a problem in sales, you've got to look at what you're doing first. Anything else is an excuse. If you're not getting enough leads, figure out a way to make it happen. If you're not happy with the pitch deck you were given, go build your own. She was really good at teaching me accountability.
[09:19] Tim Geisert: Did somebody ever sit you down and give you advice that you recall?
[09:25] Jen Allen-Knuth: I hate saying this, because I feel like people would be envious of it, but I've had one bad sales manager in my entire career, and it was a short stint. I was far enough into my career to know he was bad, so any advice he gave me, I was like, "I don't think I need to pay any attention to this." Other than that, I got so much great advice. The advice that shaped my ability to do this job — to start this company — came from a manager named Kevin Hart. Not the comedian; very different from the comedian. He was the one who said, "If you want to be exceptional, you really have to generate your own demand, and you have to be really good at it. Even if you have an SDR, you cannot rely on them." And he helped me look at my own work product. I thought I was really good at it, and I would show him my emails, and he'd say, "I tuned out at sentence two. I tuned out at your subject line." He was so tough on me — which I appreciate, as someone who thinks that if you're going to give someone tough feedback, it's because you care about where they're going and want to help them get there. His hard conversations helped me realize how much I had to grow. And today, he's in the back of my head a lot of the time when I'm working with customers. I think: what did he say to me, how did he say it, and how did he get me to realize my own gaps, versus just feeling like I was being scolded?
[10:57] Tim Geisert: Let the audience know what you do to be good at demand gen. As we study salespeople — even if you're a seasoned executive — demand gen is still one of the biggest drivers of personal and company success. What do you do to do it well? What have you learned? What advice would you give?
[11:19] Jen Allen-Knuth: I do think demand gen is different in different segments of the market, so my advice is for enterprise, which is where I've spent my entire career. I think demand gen is one of the most intellectually challenging jobs, if you do it well. What makes me successful, and what makes my clients successful, is taking the time to almost do discovery before you get to discovery: getting so curious about what this business is trying to do. What are the obstacles in the way? Where does my prospect fit into that? What are they likely already trying that maybe isn't working? And then you get down to a case for change, or a negative consequence.
When I started looking at prospecting like that, my messages became far less about — frankly, not at all about — the thing I was selling, and more about this idea: "I'm at the center of all these executives. I hear lots of ideas — some are working, some aren't. My value to you as a salesperson, before you buy anything, is to transfer those ideas and be a conduit of insight." It also took the pressure down a little. I wasn't begging people to take my meeting. I wasn't writing long pitches asking, "Are you interested in seeing a demo of this thing?" It was more like, "I saw the company just started doing this. It got me thinking this might be harder. I was just talking to a company the other day that was up against something similar. They tried a couple of things that worked and a couple that didn't. Are you open to hearing what they found?" And then when you get to the call, you don't feel like you're performing. You just feel like you can have this conversation, whether they buy right now or not — enterprise sales is a long game. It showed me you can have a truly great relationship built on the back of business acumen. So a lot of it was throwing out everything I ever learned about demand gen and saying: I've got to show up really curious about what they're trying to do, but informed. I'm not holding my hand out.
[13:07] Tim Geisert: What are you doing for demand gen?
[13:11] Jen Allen-Knuth: I'm at a very fortunate point. I started writing on LinkedIn in 2020. I said yes to every podcast, big or small. I know there are podcasts I did that never saw the light of day — never had a single listener other than the host. I still said yes, because I knew it would give me experience, and maybe there'd be one person who watched it, right? So between that, LinkedIn, and getting involved with communities where my prospects go to learn — those are the things that have made it. My business is 100% inbound, and I feel very lucky. I know that won't last forever, but my content on LinkedIn, and things like this, help someone understand my point of view. Does it align with theirs? Is it different? If it's similar, I almost feel like I've pre-tested them. So that's made it not only a good demand gen channel, but most of the people who come in already know what I think and what I believe, and that's been good for sales cycle time.
[14:12] Tim Geisert: So you spend a lot of time speaking at SKOs and working with sales leaders. What's different today versus when you first opened your doors a few years ago?
[14:23] Jen Allen-Knuth: When AI came around, I was like, "I guess I'm closing up shop. Who's going to want to hire a sales trainer?" Even in this year alone, watching the pendulum swing from "We should be automating everything" to "What should be human?" — and trying to find that right center — has been fascinating to watch. As a business owner, it has forced my hand to relook at the way I did things, experiment, and try new things, which is good. I think it's made it a more interesting career. But is it different because of AI? No. It's just the latest technical advance that people get way too excited about and then need to reground on. It feels different because it's new to everybody, and that newness makes it exciting.
[15:07] Tim Geisert: Yeah, well said. I think that's so true. I'm so old I remember when CRMs came out and how that was going to change sales. "We're not going to need as many salespeople. Everybody's going to get all the right stuff delivered at the right time, and the salespeople are going to be the smartest ever." And here we are.
[15:30] Jen Allen-Knuth: And here we are. Most salespeople hate the CRM.
[15:33] Tim Geisert: You know, the people who really like the CRM are the private equity guys who look at the data. They love it. A couple more questions. Tell me about the deal you lost that still pisses you off.
[15:42] Jen Allen-Knuth: All of them! I would say I don't tend to stay pissed off, as long as there's something I can learn. But in the moment, the deal that pissed me off the most was one I was working on with Visa — or thought I was. I worked on this deal for 11 months with the person I thought was the right title to be working with. In retrospect, I should have picked up on cues that this was going nowhere, because it was always, "I just need this new slide. I need this new deck. It needs to be done by tomorrow." He'd call me at 10 o'clock at night, I'd pick up, and I thought that certainly meant momentum and progress. But there was always a reason the next step on his side never happened.
About 11 months in, I thought, "What's the harm in inviting his boss to this event we're doing for CROs?" So I sent the boss an email, and I opened with, "I've been working with [name] on evaluating Challenger, as I'm sure you're aware, and thought this might be a great opportunity for you to meet some other folks who are farther along in the journey." Well, I got an email back: "You've been talking to who, about what?" And I was like, oh, God. Then my boss got a call from this guy. He screamed at him and said, "I'm calling her next." So my boss called me really quickly and said, "Get ready. You're about to get it." And then the guy called me and literally screamed until I was sobbing. Again, I'm not typically an emotional person about sales, but he was calling me every name in the book, because I think he got in a lot of trouble. He was never supposed to be evaluating an external methodology, and that email triggered it.
Did it piss me off? Yes, because I thought I was going to win this amazing deal — a big figure, a great logo. But it probably also taught me the most about making sure I don't misinterpret what a real champion, or agent of change, is. So that's why I can release my pissed-off-edness from that one.
[17:27] Tim Geisert: I think "pissed-off-edness" is now added to the dictionary.
[17:30] Jen Allen-Knuth: Definitely. Webster would be proud.
[17:32] Tim Geisert: Jen, thank you so much for your time. This was really insightful. Good luck to you — I'm sure you'll be wildly successful — and let's keep in touch.
[17:42] Jen Allen-Knuth: Absolutely. And that's the best hat I've ever seen on a podcast, so thank you for rocking it.
[17:47] Tim Geisert: As a bald man, I love almost any hat, especially this one. Nice to meet you, Jen.
[17:52] Jen Allen-Knuth: Nice to meet you, Tim. Thank you.